Book Review: Calico by Lee Goldberg
From the moment I stumbled upon Lee Goldberg’s Calico, I knew this novel would draw me in with its blend of mystery and a rich historical backdrop. The vivid imagery of a dusty desert town, once a bustling hub in the 1800s, juxtaposed with a modern detective story felt like the perfect recipe for an engaging read. As a lover of mysteries that delve into the past, I felt almost nostalgic anticipation unfurling within me.
Set in Barstow, California, Calico introduces us to Detective Beth McDade—a woman navigating the murky waters of personal and professional turmoil after losing her badge in Los Angeles. What makes Beth’s character compelling is her blend of resilience and vulnerability. She’s not just a detective; she’s a woman grappling with her identity in a town where “nobody wants to be.” This blend made me root for her, while also getting frustrated at her tendency to throw herself into transient relationships as a means of coping. It was a bit jarring, reflecting a “male fantasy writing” trope that didn’t sit quite right with me. However, Beth is authentic in her struggles, making her a multi-dimensional character I appreciated.
The initial mystery unfolds dramatically when Beth is called to investigate an old man’s tragic death near Peggy Sue’s diner—a quirky spot resembling a giant jukebox surrounded by dinosaurs. The details in this scene are a testament to Goldberg’s ability to weave an atmosphere that feels tangible. When Beth discovers CCTV footage revealing a bizarre electrical charge and a flash from a nearby Marine base, the plot thickens. This opening sets the tone for an investigation that only gets more twisted as Beth finds connections to missing persons, including an L.A. chef named Owen Slader.
Goldberg’s writing style shines through with vivid descriptions of both Barstow’s current state and the eerie historical echoes of Calico. The seamless transitions between the present-day investigation and the 1880s’ silver rush draw the reader deeper into the narrative. I found myself vividly imagining the stench and chaos of the old mining town—red dust coating the streets and miners with weary, unwashed faces mingling with laughs and shouts from the saloon. Amidst this historical turmoil, the present-day crime investigation keeps the pacing brisk and engaging.
One of the highlights of the book for me was the moment Beth uncovers a buried coffin linked to Slader. This revelation is not only shocking, but it also serves as an excellent plot device to bridge past and present. The interwoven timelines create a rich tapestry that serves to deepen both the themes of mystery and the exploration of human nature.
While I wrestled with some aspects of Beth’s character, the plot twists and surprises more than made up for it. Goldberg manages to tackle not just a central mystery, but various side plots that keep the narrative fresh and unpredictable.
In summary, Calico is a multifaceted read that I think will resonate with fans of historical mysteries and contemporary thrillers alike. If you love a story that combines vivid historical detail with a compelling present-day narrative, then this book is for you. It left me reflecting on the connections between past and present, and how sometimes, our history might just come back to haunt us in the most unexpected ways.
A big thank you to Netgalley, Lee Goldberg, and Severn House for allowing me to dive into this riveting journey. I can’t wait to hear what you all think—feel free to share your thoughts in the comments below or follow me for more reviews at Reviews by Barb Saffer!
Discover more about Calico on GoodReads >>