Book Review: City of Ashes (The Mortal Instruments, #2) by Cassandra Clare
When I picked up City of Ashes, the second installment in Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments series, I was eager to dive back into the shadowy world of Downworlders, Nephilim, and the complex relationships that thrived amid the chaos. Clare’s imaginative universe had left its mark on me in the first book, and I was both apprehensive and excited to see where it would take me next.
As I navigated through City of Ashes, I found myself grappling more with personal feelings towards the characters than the plot itself. The blend of action, romance, and supernatural elements is heightened, yet my biggest struggle lay within the character dynamics. In this installment, the relationship between Alec and Magnus took center stage, yet it didn’t resonate with me as much as I hoped it would. My reading experience mirrored that of John’s sister, who expressed, with a sprinkle of frustration, how the lack of chemistry made her cringe. Magnus’s charm is undeniable, but I couldn’t shake off the unsettling vibes he exuded—a combination of charm and creepiness that seemed disproportionate for a centuries-old warlock.
The tension between Alec’s insecurities and Magnus’s flamboyance offered fertile ground for exploration, yet Clare’s execution felt flat at times. Alec’s internal struggle with his identity and love was touching, but I couldn’t help but question why Magnus was drawn to him. Were they connecting on anything deeper than mere attraction? This feeling of “x = no chemistry” echoed throughout my reading.
But let’s talk about Jace for a moment—he’s as compelling as he is infuriating. His brooding angst defines a considerable chunk of the narrative, prompting some empathetic but also visceral reactions. It feels like Clare intended him to be a tragic hero, but I found myself perplexed by his self-absorbed antics—he might be haunted by his past, yet it doesn’t excuse his jerkish behavior. I felt compelled to shake some sense into him throughout the book, grappling with my love-hate relationship with his character.
However, amid the tangled web of relationships and angst, Clare’s writing style shines through. Her ability to craft vivid imagery and palpable tension carved out a fascinating backdrop for the unfolding drama. While certain character arcs felt underwhelming, Clare’s prose kept me engaged, prompting me to flip through the pages even amidst my critiques.
Memorable quotes dotted throughout the text encapsulate Clare’s signature wit and emotion, sparking fleeting moments of delight. Yet, those tender moments were often overshadowed by repetitive plot devices. I couldn’t help but wish for a bit more creativity when it came to the conflict resolution—after all, finding fresh ways to heighten tension is no easy feat.
In conclusion, City of Ashes is for readers invested in complex, if not perplexing, relationships filled with deep internal conflicts and supernatural backdrops. If you relish stories brimming with angst and moral dilemmas, Clare’s work might just satisfy your thirst. However, be forewarned—tensions can feel stuck in a loop, eliciting a mix of frustration and intrigue.
As for me, this journey through the shadowy underbelly of the Mortal Instruments universe was a rollercoaster, splashed with dissatisfaction at times but purchased with vivid prose that kept me hooked. I look forward to what’s next, albeit with a dash of wariness about where these characters will take me.
Discover more about City of Ashes (The Mortal Instruments, #2) on GoodReads >>