Review of Insurgent (Divergent, #2) by Veronica Roth
Insurgent caught my eye not just because I was eager to dive deeper into Veronica Roth’s intricate dystopian world, but also due to the lingering questions left by Divergent. The first book had that thrilling momentum, full of discovery and tension, and I was curious to see how Tris and Tobias would navigate the fallout of their choices. However, let me tell you right up front: this second installment was a mixed bag for me.
Let’s start with the things that irked me. Right off the bat, the book’s length—over 500 pages—felt like a slow march through a labyrinth of dialogues and reflections. While Divergent whisked me away, Insurgent had me checking the page count with an impatient sigh. Characters seemed to linger in spaces, brooding and debating while the tension of the plot felt painfully deferred. I found myself wishing for a red pen to trim about 200 pages of fluff; after all, who hasn’t wanted to jump up and shoot the wall out of boredom sometimes?
Then there’s Tris. Oh, Tris, you started as a compelling protagonist, but how quickly you devolved into a frustrating caricature of angst! I empathized with her guilt over Will’s death, but the relentless self-recrimination felt excessive. It was as if Roth wanted to emphasize her struggle to the point of redundancy. I couldn’t help but shout internally, “We get it! Move on!” The ease with which Christina forgave Tris after such a heavy betrayal felt implausible and just a tad too convenient, detracting from the emotional weight of the moment.
And Tobias, our brooding hero, became another source of irritation for me. The mysterious layers that made him appealing in Divergent seemed to dissolve into a mess of anger and hostility. His reaction to being called a coward felt juvenile and wasn’t the resilient character arc I was hoping to see. Plus, his treatment of Tris oscillated uncomfortably between affection and scorn, leaving me questioning his intentions and undermining their bond.
However, not all was bleak. The secondary characters, particularly Lynn and Uriah, sparked my interest more than our leads. Lynn’s revelation about her sexuality was a refreshing moment, even if it felt like a token gesture before her untimely demise. Roth’s world-building improved significantly—she unlocked more of the dystopian mechanics, especially surrounding the simulations, which I found conceptually intriguing! The exploration of fear through Tobias’s landscapes might just be the most thought-provoking concept to come from the book. There’s something deliciously terrifying about confronting one’s fears head-on, and I think many readers could relate to that struggle.
And let’s not overlook the shocking twist involving Caleb. I confess, I bristled at the abrupt turn to “BWAHAHA, I’m evil!” without enough foreshadowing. It felt like a narrative shortcut that detracted from the otherwise intricate plot journey.
In conclusion, while Insurgent didn’t quite match the exhilarating pulse of its predecessor, it certainly set the stage for what promises to be a compelling finale. Fans of Divergent will likely find enough here to keep them invested—especially in that tantalizing cliffhanger! While it had its flaws, I still enjoyed the book as I anticipate where Roth will take her characters next. If you enjoyed Divergent and are curious about the mechanics of this world—or are simply invested in seeing how Tris and Tobias evolve—Insurgent may be worth adding to your reading list. What was your impression? Let’s chat about it!
Discover more about Insurgent (Divergent, #2) on GoodReads >>