Reflecting on Time and Loss in The Expert of Subtle Revisions by J.A. Menger-Anderson
As a lover of stories that stretch the boundaries of time and identity, I was immediately drawn to J.A. Menger-Anderson’s The Expert of Subtle Revisions. The promise of a time travel narrative focused on themes as weighty as fascism, love, and the erasure of women intrigued me. While I often struggle with time travel tropes—believing they fail when you peel back the layers—I dove in with an open heart, eager to see what insights lay within the pages.
The novel spans two timelines and centers around Hase, a reclusive woman in 2016 San Francisco, who is on a quest to find her elusive father. She is paired with Anton, a brilliant, closeted mathematician grappling with his own identity in 1930s Austria, and Josef, a resentful waiter lashing out against the world. Interwoven through their narratives is Haskell, a whimsical mathematical genius whose fantastical music box allows him to traverse time, desperately seeking to amend the tragic fates tied to his life and the lives of Anton and Josef.
Menger-Anderson’s exploration of fascism struck a chord with me. Josef embodies the poison of narcissism, echoing broader societal themes of anti-intellectualism and violence. His character teeters between grim humor and chilling seriousness, serving as a harsh reminder of how destructive individualism can become when cloaked in the guise of ambition. This duality is skillfully balanced with the warmth found in Anton and Haskell’s tender relationship—a romantic and intellectual connection that transcends time. Their love blooms amid the backdrop of impending disaster, creating a heart-wrenching sense of urgency that truly resonated with me.
It’s hard not to get swept away by Menger-Anderson’s prose, which dances on the line between lyrical and raw. The author’s ability to depict the emotional landscape of desire and the nuanced dance of intellect and affection left an indelible mark on my reading experience. Melancholic beauty also permeates Hase’s journey, pulling at the existential threads that connect us to our parents and our pasts.
Yet, the theme of women’s erasure lingered in my mind like a slight stitch in the fabric of the narrative. The jacket copy asserts the importance of this erasure, but at times, it felt like a surface exploration. Hase’s struggle for agency is poignant, yet I couldn’t shake the feeling that her arc was overshadowed by the men around her, inadvertently echoing the very theme that the book aims to critique. The insight into characters like Fraulein Popovic, who shine through the cracks, left me wanting more; I wished for deeper dives into their hearts and minds instead of footnotes to male experiences.
Despite these complexities, The Expert of Subtle Revisions is a triumph of thought and emotion. It stretches our understanding of history, love, and the consequences of our choices. Menger-Anderson compels us to reflect on how we navigate the shadows of our legacies and the legacy of those who came before us.
In conclusion, I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone interested in stories that blend intellectual rigor with emotional depth. Fans of historical fiction, time travel narratives, or even just those who enjoy a well-turned phrase will find something to cherish here. For me, this reading journey was a gentle reminder that nothing is ever as simple as it seems; the winding path of understanding our parents can lead us to unexpected, wondrous—and sometimes heartbreaking—revelations.
Discover more about The Expert of Subtle Revisions on GoodReads >>