When Love Gives You Lemons: A Sweet Idea, but a Sour Taste
When I first heard about When Love Gives You Lemons by Steven Salvatore, I was instantly intrigued. A coming-of-age romance set on a picturesque lemon farm? As someone who loves vibrant settings and heartfelt narratives, I couldn’t resist diving into this colorful world. However, my experience with this book ended up being quite disappointing, and I felt compelled to share my thoughts with you all.
At its core, When Love Gives You Lemons attempts to tackle important themes of identity and love, particularly within the LGBTQIA+ spectrum. The lemon farm is undeniably lovely, serving as a picturesque backdrop for a story about young love. The lush, fragrant orchards and sun-soaked landscapes evoke a sense of warmth that’s hard not to appreciate. But, as the reader moves beyond the setting, the characters and plot begin to falter.
The protagonist’s journey revolves around his complicated relationship with Ricky, his childhood best friend and first love. While the foundation is there, the chemistry just isn’t. Their interactions felt as flat as a day-old soda—certain moments hinted at deeper emotions, but they fizzled out almost immediately. I found myself questioning why these two were so drawn to each other when their encounters felt more like obligatory scenes rather than genuine sparks. The whole “best friends to lovers” trope, which usually brings such promise, felt entirely wasted here.
One major issue worth addressing is the book’s handling of LGBTQIA+ representation, particularly the asexual, aromantic, and agender identities. There’s a character who is queerness-adjacent yet falls into the trap of queerphobia, merely reinforcing negative stereotypes. The missed opportunity to highlight the diversity within the acronym felt like a significant oversight. It’s a narrative choice that, while not the sole reason for my dissatisfaction, detracted from the book’s potential message and could alienate readers who identify with those identities.
On a lighter note, I found myself puzzled by a few quirky elements that bordered on the petty. Is Fielder Lemon really a name a person would have? It sounds like something out of a whimsical children’s book rather than the leading character of a romantic journey! Not to mention the cringe-worthy insistence on referring to TikTok as the "Clock App," which only made me roll my eyes.
Add to this the structural choices made by Salvatore, such as the frequent breaking of the fourth wall that took me out of the narrative instead of drawing me in, and the result is a patchwork book that never really feels cohesive. Moments that should have been charged with emotion fell flat due to what felt like miscommunication between characters and the author.
Despite these grievances, I do think there may be readers who find some joy in When Love Gives You Lemons. Those who cherish light-hearted romances or are readers curious about the nuances of young adulthood might still find some enjoyment. For others, like myself, it might feel like a missed opportunity—one that could have been ripe with emotional depth but ultimately left a sour taste.
If you enjoy warm settings and stories that flirt with themes of identity, you might still be tempted to pick it up, but approach with tempered expectations. Perhaps it’ll resonate more with you than it did with me. Let’s raise a glass of lemonade to the prospect of sweeter reads ahead!
Discover more about When Love Gives You Lemons on GoodReads >>